While I am more than happy for you to make a local map out of that area for the atlas if you want to do that, it is after all quite a large area that might contain lots more villages than seen on the rather large-scale main map (Just check out that local map already made in that small rectangular area in the middle), remember that the competition is about creating a map of a single village, so I wouldn't be able to accept such an area map for the competition.

Of course, if you want to make a local area map, and then a village map of one of the villages in the new local area map, that would be perfectly fine, but otherwise, you should pick one of the villages in the area to map, not the entire area.

I'd just like to point out one thing here that may be of interest though. From the article Derek posted, several of the VTT's only supported it because the community wrote a script/importer/plugin.

Community effort is a great thing, and for a thing like this, maybe someone in the community would consider writing their own add-on to CC3+ to support this? Of course, this does require a bit of programming, but if C++ doesn't scare you, all you need to get started is here:

One should be able to gather more or less all the information needed by walking the drawing list and process the values.

And the final map processed for now. Probably won't process any more before the competition ends now.

For some reason, I completely missed this post. My sincere apologies for that. I've now processed this map and included it in the atlas.

Unfortunately, as a result of me missing this submission, I thought this not completed, and deleted the reservation as I do with all reservations that gets too old, and Quenten picked it up, and did his version of the island.

So while there is no way to make this perfect, I think the best option is just to include both versions in the atlas. I guess we can call it some alternate reality magical zone, the islands from two different worlds that keep switching worlds for some unknown reason (adventure hook).

So, my apologies to both of you, and thanks for your submissions.

Here's both the maps:

Could you attach the .fcw here? I'd like to have a little look at it, and see if I can replicate the problem on my computer and have a look at those problematic polygons and maybe send it off to the devloper.

I am guessing fewer people have the free version simply because the annuals have more reach to customers not part of the community, but on the other hand, they are free, so anyone can get them without purchasing anything.

And yes, I used the free ones for my map. They're listed among the allowed resources here (the "Free Addons" section).

That's completely up to you.

The main thing I very strongly encourage when making a non-overland map, is that there is a symbol (or equivalent) on the parent map to link it to. No making an inn and linking it to a blank spot near the road on the parent map because "there could feasibly be an inn here". It is the mappers responsibility to place interesting places in their maps for others to link from, and if no marker for such an interesting place exist on the map, well, then an intermediate map may be required. So generally, the idea with an intermediary map is to make up for "shortcomings" of the parent map.

Well, historically, an Inn provides accommodation, it didn't have to double as a tavern. So two Inns and a Tavern doesn't have to mean 3 drinking places.

Since the local populace doesn't really need an Inn, they have their homes, two Inns may also indicate the place gets lots of travelers spending the night. and who likes to have a drink when finally not spending the night in a campsite.

Size of each place is also a factor, a small place may only fit 20-30 people, or even less, and if they serve as meeting place for the populace in the evenings, even 3 places isn't necessarily that extravagant for a population of say 300, as they would still only accommodate a small fraction of the populace, not including travelers passing by.

Lots of vastly different maps from different mappers with different ways of approaching things, that is one of the things that make the atlas (and the competition) great. I love all the great variety of the maps in the atlas, some focusing on visual looks, others on accuracy and yet others on the story they tell.

Well, you can still submit it to the competition if you plan to make a regional map later. There are several other participants submitting villages from yet-unfinished regional maps. Nearly a full day until the deadline.