Community Atlas 1000th map Competition - Please Vote (Even if you didn't participate yourself)

MonsenMonsen Administrator 🖼️ 81 images Cartographer

The 1000th atlas map competition is now over, and below is the voting and gallery of the entries into this year's competition. Please vote for your favorite ones, even if you didn't participate in the contest yourself. We want as many votes as possible to ensure the fairest result.

The voting period will end on Sunday October 20th, 22:00:00 UTC.

Remember, these maps are fighting for the recognition of being the best maps in the competition, with ProFantasy store vouchers for the top 3.

I've shown all entries in the post below, but some maps at the end are excluded from the actual voting, these being mine, Sue's and Ralf's due to us either working for ProFantasy or arranging this contest. Also note that the rules stipulated one price per mapper, so should someone the same mapper have two maps in the top 3, they will only get the best prize they qualify for, the other prize will move downwards in the list to the next eligible contestant. This also applies to the prize for the randomly drawn 1000th atlas map which will also be announced at the end of the voting.

If you prefer to view the submissions in the image gallery viewer, this link leads to the first entry, and you can use the arrows in the top right to navigate back and forth.

Below, you will find three poll questions, to decide which map you prefer for first, second and third points. I'll give the maps points based on your votes (8 points for a first place vote, 5 points for a second place vote, and 3 points for a third place vote) and at the end of the voting period I will tally up the points and present the final list.

Some mappers have submitted more than one map to the competition. If you want to give them one of your votes, but do not prefer any one map of theirs above another, I recommend giving the vote to the first of their maps in the list. This allows them to collect most of their votes on one map instead of being randomly spread over them which hurts their chances since we are voting for best map, not best mapper.

For voting, please don't just consider how visually pleasing the map is, but also take into account the premise of the competition. Does it represent a conceivable fantasy village? Is it an interesting adventure location? Is the map good work by the mapper, or is the beauty just in the style they picked?

And to to all the contestants, please don't despair if your map gets very few or even no votes, it doesn't mean people dislike your map. But since we are only voting for the top 3 and not ranking every map, and due to the fact that these competitions don't get too many voters in total, most votes will tend to go to a small selection of the maps.

  1. Your pick for best map25 votes
    1. 1. Ricko Hasche - Metzvel
      36.00%
    2. 2. Royal Scribe - Fon'Anor
        4.00%
    3. 3. Royal Scribe - Village of Djayet
        4.00%
    4. 4. Royal Scribe - Eilân Danaäd
        4.00%
    5. 5. Royal Scribe - Yréas Kóltyn Village
        0.00%
    6. 6. Royal Scribe - Vidural Village & Mines
        0.00%
    7. 7. Royal Scribe - Arbor Hollow
        0.00%
    8. 8. Mathieu Gans - Argenta
        0.00%
    9. 9. Wyvern - Ljungby Village
        4.00%
    10. 10. Wyvern - Bruga's Hold
        0.00%
    11. 11. Wyvern - Ivan's Keep
        0.00%
    12. 12. Wyvern - The Village of Toresk
        0.00%
    13. 13. Wyvern - Osalin
        0.00%
    14. 14. Wyvern - Arvika
        8.00%
    15. 15. Wyvern - Rularn
        0.00%
    16. 16. Wyvern - Brightlawn
        0.00%
    17. 17. Wyvern - Fairbridge
        0.00%
    18. 18. Wyvern - Skara
        0.00%
    19. 19. Quayuazue - Phindardol's Gate
        4.00%
    20. 20. cyrion - Sibad Oasis
        4.00%
    21. 21. Quenten - Aretizo
        8.00%
    22. 22. Shessar - Ober
      16.00%
    23. 23. HelenAA - Bittern's Rest
        0.00%
    24. 24. Daniel Pereda De Pablo - Efva Talesi
        0.00%
    25. 25. Jeff B - Ingensteds
        4.00%
    26. 26. MakeWayForJebus - Order of the Fist Monastery
        0.00%
    27. 27. Lorelei - Naru Village
        4.00%
  2. Your pick for 2nd place25 votes
    1. 1. Ricko Hasche - Metzvel
      24.00%
    2. 2. Royal Scribe - Fon'Anor
        4.00%
    3. 3. Royal Scribe - Village of Djayet
        8.00%
    4. 4. Royal Scribe - Eilân Danaäd
        4.00%
    5. 5. Royal Scribe - Yréas Kóltyn Village
        4.00%
    6. 6. Royal Scribe - Vidural Village & Mines
        8.00%
    7. 7. Royal Scribe - Arbor Hollow
        4.00%
    8. 8. Mathieu Gans - Argenta
        4.00%
    9. 9. Wyvern - Ljungby Village
        4.00%
    10. 10. Wyvern - Bruga's Hold
        0.00%
    11. 11. Wyvern - Ivan's Keep
        0.00%
    12. 12. Wyvern - The Village of Toresk
        0.00%
    13. 13. Wyvern - Osalin
        0.00%
    14. 14. Wyvern - Arvika
        0.00%
    15. 15. Wyvern - Rularn
        0.00%
    16. 16. Wyvern - Brightlawn
        0.00%
    17. 17. Wyvern - Fairbridge
        0.00%
    18. 18. Wyvern - Skara
        0.00%
    19. 19. Quayuazue - Phindardol's Gate
        0.00%
    20. 20. cyrion - Sibad Oasis
        0.00%
    21. 21. Quenten - Aretizo
        4.00%
    22. 22. Shessar - Ober
        4.00%
    23. 23. HelenAA - Bittern's Rest
        4.00%
    24. 24. Daniel Pereda De Pablo - Efva Talesi
        4.00%
    25. 25. Jeff B - Ingensteds
        0.00%
    26. 26. MakeWayForJebus - Order of the Fist Monastery
        0.00%
    27. 27. Lorelei - Naru Village
      20.00%
  3. Your pick for 3rd place25 votes
    1. 1. Ricko Hasche - Metzvel
        8.00%
    2. 2. Royal Scribe - Fon'Anor
      12.00%
    3. 3. Royal Scribe - Village of Djayet
        0.00%
    4. 4. Royal Scribe - Eilân Danaäd
        0.00%
    5. 5. Royal Scribe - Yréas Kóltyn Village
        4.00%
    6. 6. Royal Scribe - Vidural Village & Mines
        4.00%
    7. 7. Royal Scribe - Arbor Hollow
        0.00%
    8. 8. Mathieu Gans - Argenta
      16.00%
    9. 9. Wyvern - Ljungby Village
        0.00%
    10. 10. Wyvern - Bruga's Hold
        0.00%
    11. 11. Wyvern - Ivan's Keep
        0.00%
    12. 12. Wyvern - The Village of Toresk
        0.00%
    13. 13. Wyvern - Osalin
        0.00%
    14. 14. Wyvern - Arvika
        4.00%
    15. 15. Wyvern - Rularn
        0.00%
    16. 16. Wyvern - Brightlawn
        0.00%
    17. 17. Wyvern - Fairbridge
        0.00%
    18. 18. Wyvern - Skara
        0.00%
    19. 19. Quayuazue - Phindardol's Gate
        0.00%
    20. 20. cyrion - Sibad Oasis
        4.00%
    21. 21. Quenten - Aretizo
        8.00%
    22. 22. Shessar - Ober
      12.00%
    23. 23. HelenAA - Bittern's Rest
        4.00%
    24. 24. Daniel Pereda De Pablo - Efva Talesi
        4.00%
    25. 25. Jeff B - Ingensteds
      12.00%
    26. 26. MakeWayForJebus - Order of the Fist Monastery
        4.00%
    27. 27. Lorelei - Naru Village
        4.00%
LoopysueWyvern

Comments

  • MonsenMonsen Administrator 🖼️ 81 images Cartographer
    edited October 6

    1. Ricko Hasche - Metzvel


    2. Royal Scribe - Fon'Anor


    3. Royal Scribe - Village of Djayet


    4. Royal Scribe - Eilân Danaäd


    5. Royal Scribe - Yréas Kóltyn Village


    6. Royal Scribe - Vidural Village & Mines


    7. Royal Scribe - Arbor Hollow


    8. Mathieu Gans - Argenta


    9. Wyvern - Ljungby Village


    10. Wyvern - Bruga's Hold


    11. Wyvern - Ivan's Keep


    12. Wyvern - The Village of Toresk


    13. Wyvern - Osalin


    14. Wyvern - Arvika


    15. Wyvern - Rularn


    16. Wyvern - Brightlawn


    17. Wyvern - Fairbridge


    18. Wyvern - Skara


    19. Quayuazue - Phindardol's Gate


    20. cyrion - Sibad Oasis


    21. Quenten - Aretizo


    22. Shessar - Ober


    23. HelenAA - Bittern's Rest


    24. Daniel Pereda De Pablo - Efva Talesi


    25. Jeff B - Ingensteds


    26. MakeWayForJebus - Order of the Fist Monastery


    27. Lorelei - Naru Village


    Loopysue - Elkton


    Monsen - Port Haven


    Ralf - The Frontier Village of Rheems


    Return to the voting poll.

    LoopysueRoyal ScribeWyvernRicko HascheAleD
  • As usual with such competitions, there are far too many entries deserving of the top places, and far too few votes available per person to vote for all I might wish!

    I do think it's important to emphasize again that everyone who took part deserves our praise and admiration. There's not a single map here that won't grace the Atlas with its presence.

    And they'll also have pushed us on way beyond Map 1,000 once they've all been added to the Atlas.

    Well done to one and all, regardless of what the final results may show!

    LoopysueRoyal ScribeGlitchAleD
  • LoopysueLoopysue ProFantasy 🖼️ 40 images Cartographer

    I agree with Wyvern.

    Congratulations on some really lovely maps everyone!

    I'm still having trouble deciding how to vote...

    AleD
  • I'm having problems too, but I think I've decided.

    AleD
  • Oh my... so many beautiful maps!

    Thanks to all the participants for the effort and for letting us admire them!

    It is a very hard choice!

Sign In or Register to comment.